RC Adv Doc Q53
Essay #16.
The United States hospital industry is an unusual market in that nonprofit and for-profit producers exist simultaneously. Theoretical literature offers conflicting views on whether nonprofit hospitals are less financially efficient. Theory suggests that nonprofit hospitals are so much more interested in offering high-quality service than in making money that they frequently input more resources to provide the same output of service as for-profit hospitals. This priority might also often lead them to be less vigilant in streamlining their services–eliminating duplication between departments, for instance. Conversely, while profit motive is thought to encourage for-profit hospitals to attain efficient production, most theorists admit that obstacles to that efficiency remain. For-profit hospital
managers, for example, generally work independently of hospital owners and thus may not always make maximum financial efficiency their highest priority. The literature also suggests that widespread adoption of third-party payment systems may eventually eliminate any such potential differences between the two kinds of hospitals.
The same literature offers similarly conflicting views of the efficiency of nonprofit hospitals from a social welfare perspective.Newhouse (1970) contends that nonprofit hospital managers unnecessarily expand the quality and quantity of hospital care beyond the actual needs of the community, while Weisbrod (1975) argues that nonprofit firms–hospitals included–contribute efficiently to community welfare by providing public services that might be inadequately provided by government alone.
Question #53.
According to the passage, Newhouse’s view of the social welfare efficiency of nonprofit hospitals differs from Weisbrod’s view in that Newhouse
(A) contends that government already provides most of the services that communities need
(B) argues that for-profit hospitals are better at meeting actual community needs than are nonprofit hospitals
(C) argues that nonprofit hospitals are likely to spend more to provide services that the community requires than for-profit hospitals are likely to spend
(D) argues that nonprofit hospitals ought to expand the services they provide to meet the
community’s demands
(E) believes that the level of care provided by nonprofit hospitals is inappropriate, given the community’s requirements
OA is E.
I did not consider E option due to the word “Inappropriate” which means not suitable. As per the passage, Newhouse provides hospital care beyond the actual needs of the community, which means they are providing the needed hospital care, and are overdoing it.
I chose option C because of this confusion, even though it compares between the spends of non-profit and for-profit hospitals which is outside the information presented in the passage, on second thought.
Can someone tell me if this word “Inappropriate” is apt in this context?
IMO, anything that is ‘beyond or less’ than the requirement would fall into the inappropriate category.
Appropriate means the exactly the same as what is required.
Thanks.
Hello,
This has already been discussed here http://www.crackverbal.com/forum/threads/RC%20Adv%20Doc_Set%20II_Essay%207_United%20States%20Hospital/383
Please make sure you use the “search” function to check if a question has been discussed already before starting a new thread.
Thank you! 🙂
