x, y and z are real numbers, is xy>0?

x, y and z are real numbers, is xy>0?

(1) xz>0

(2) zy>0

 

I answered E because x,y,z all three can be -ve in which case answer will be -ve i.e < 0  but the CV Quant test says right answer is C

 

Intermediate Asked on July 18, 2017 in Data Sufficiency.
Add Comment
2 Answer(s)

Hi Sabicha,

Yes x,y,z all could be negative.

But in that case, still x * y is positive .

Question is about product of two numbers x and y, not all three.

So the answer is C.

Expert Answered on July 19, 2017.
Add Comment

xz>0 –> not enough information on y  so A is not the right option

yz> 0 –> not enough information on x  so B is not the right option

and also D goes down with this.

now multiply these two. statement , Remember  + * + = +

So zx * yz >0

=> xy* z^2 >0

as z^2 is always >0  So we can remove it.

So we  have xy >0  which is enough to answer question Is xy>0 ?  answer is  yes

 

This make C as correct

( BTW if z= 0 none of the above statement hold true  so we have to consider z as non zero.)

Intermediate Answered on July 20, 2017.
Add Comment

Your Answer

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.